Put these 5 fighters in order of Greatness

[#1Assassin]

Joey Giardello
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney
Rid**** Bowe
Naseem Hamed

1. James Toney
2. Rid**** Bowe
3. Joey Giardello
4. Naseem Hamed
5. Joe Calzaghe

bowe and giardello coulve gon either way, the other spots are solid. toney is a level above bowe and giardello imo, and clearly a couple of levels above naz and calzaghe. like i said bowe and giardello could go either way, then naz and calzaghe is clearly dead last. they did a great job of picking his fights, the fighter himself is little more than ordinary.

[joelab75]

calzhage
toney
giardello
bowe
hamed

[The Surgeon]

Toney
Giardello
Bowe
Naz
Calzaghe

[Kid McCoy]

Giardello first. Though inconsistent, his best wins against **** Tiger, Henry Hank, Holly Mims, Rubin Carter, Billy Graham and Gene Fullmer (scored a draw but he was unlucky not get the win and Fullmer should have been DQ'd) are superior to any of the others. Toney next, then Calzaghe, then Hamed and Bowe last.

Bowe was talented but other than the first Holyfield fight he did little else in his career. Lazy and ill-disciplined, binned his belt rather than face Lewis, never fought most of the top heavyweights of the 90s, and had the snot beaten out of him by the second best prime contender he faced. Twice.

[katsidis]

Toney
Calzaghe
Giardello
Hamed
Bowe