Put these 5 fighters in order of Greatness

[Joey Giardello]

Joey Giardello
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney
Rid**** Bowe
Naseem Hamed

[SBleeder]

Calzaghe
Toney
Bowe
Giardello
Hamed

[CarlosG815]

Toney
Bowe
Hamed
Giardello
Calzaghe

[cotto16]

Joey Giardello
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney
Rid**** Bowe
Naseem Hamed

James Toney
Rid**** Bowe
Joey Giardello
Joe Calzaghe
Naseem Hamed

[derekg89]

James Toney
Joey Giardello
Naseem Hamed
Joe Calzaghe
Rid**** Bowe

[BennyST]

Why is everyone putting Bowe above the others? Although brilliant, it was too brief. I can't honestly put him above any of the others really.

I think I'd have it something like:
Giardello
Toney
Calzaghe
Hamed
Bowe

[blaze778]

James Toney
Joey Giardello
Naseem Hamed
Rid**** Bowe
Joe Calzaghe

(I'd like to put Bowe 2nd, but he had a short career and was too much of an underachiever).

[r.burgundy]

calzhaghe
bowe
toney
giardello
hamed

[BennyST]

calzhaghe
bowe
toney
giardello
hamed

Giardello and Toney below Bowe? Please explain.

[SBleeder]

Why is everyone putting Bowe above the others? Although brilliant, it was too brief. I can't honestly put him above any of the others really.

I think I'd have it something like:
Giardello
Toney
Calzaghe
Hamed
Bowe

What is it about Giardello and Toney that justify them being ranked ahead of Calzaghe? I understand your logic about Bowe, although I personally tend to rank fighters more by skill than by resume, longevity, etc.