1986/25 years

[RubenSonny]

1. Whitaker
2. Jones
3. Holyfield
4. McCallum
5. Pacquaio
6. Chavez
7. Mayweather
8. Nelson
9. Hopkins
10. Lopez
11. Morales
12. Barrera
13. Toney
14. Winky
15. Trinidad
16. Too Sharp
17. Tapia
18. De La Hoya
19. Castillo
20. Canizales

Rough listing.

[McGoorty]

[QUOTE=RubenSonny;11112107]

Manny Paquiao..... Lennox Lewis ...... Kostya Tszyu ..... Roy Jones Jr. .... Floyd Mayweather Jr..................... But that was a quick pick.... I may replace two of them, but noy Manny and Lennox..... they are certainties.[/QUOTE]

I couldn't disagree more.

Disagree all you like....... no hints to who should be let out ??????............. it was a rush job.......... I considered Whittaker... maybe I'd replace Floyd with him...... I won't leave Pacquiao out UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES.

[McGoorty]

1. Whitaker
2. Jones
3. Holyfield
4. McCallum
5. Pacquaio
6. Chavez
7. Mayweather
8. Nelson
9. Hopkins
10. Lopez
11. Morales
12. Barrera
13. Toney
14. Winky
15. Trinidad
16. Too Sharp
17. Tapia
18. De La Hoya
19. Castillo
20. Canizales

Rough listing.

McCallum at four ??????..... Holyfield above Lewis ???... hmmm.

[RubenSonny]

[QUOTE=McGoorty;11112536]

Disagree all you like....... no hints to who should be let out ??????............. it was a rush job.......... I considered Whittaker... maybe I'd replace Floyd with him...... I won't leave Pacquiao out UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES.

Take a look at my top 20, I think Pac should be in the top 5, hes on a completely different level to Louis and so are the top 10 of my list.

[IronDanHamza]

[QUOTE=McGoorty;11112536]

Disagree all you like....... no hints to who should be let out ??????............. it was a rush job.......... I considered Whittaker... maybe I'd replace Floyd with him...... I won't leave Pacquiao out UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES.

I just can't see how Lennox Lewis can be considered a greater fighter than Evander Holyfield.

I also personally can't see him being the Top 5 fighters from 1986-present.

But that's just me.

[McGoorty]

No order

McCallum
Barrera
Hopkins
Jones
Chavez

Now that's a truly laughable list..... so you never saw Barrera Vs Pacquiao....... That is a list of your favourite boxers........ this is supposed to be about the best...... not about fanboy fantasy's ................. As John McEnroe once said,..."You Caaaan't be seeerious".

[IronDanHamza]

[QUOTE=RubenSonny;11112549]

Take a look at my top 20, I think Pac should be in the top 5, hes on a completely different level to Louis and so are the top 10 of my list.

I think as low as your #13 could be argued.

I mean, for example Erik Morales, I can't see how Lewis is greater than Erik Morales.

[SCtrojansbaby]

Now that's a truly laughable list..... so you never saw Barrera Vs Pacquiao....... That is a list of your favourite boxers........ this is supposed to be about the best...... not about fanboy fantasy's ................. As John McEnroe once said,..."You Caaaan't be seeerious".

H2H isn't everything Barrera>Pacquiao but styles make fights and Pacquiao has the perfect style to beat Barrera.

[SCtrojansbaby]

I am going to expand the list to 13

1.Jones
2.Chavez
3.Barrera
4.McCallum
5.Hopkins
6.Pacquiao
7.Holyfield
8.Eubank
9.Gonzalez
10.R.Marquez
11.Nelson
12.Morales
13.Lewis

[New England]

pacquiao
hopkins
whitaker
chavez
mayweather


no order whatsoever


those who did the most for the sport in terms of draw and dollaz?

pacquiao
mayweather
de la hoya
tyson
chavez

again, no order



fastest:
camacho
jones
gamboa (yeah, he's green, but his speed is superhuman)
tyson
whitaker


i flew through these. i'll probably kick myself for some omissions later.
and none of them are in order


if anybody wants to go through power i'd love to see people's selections.

i started to make one on pure talent, but it proved too difficult to whittle it down to five in a reasonable amount of time.