Casino vs Goodfellas

[b Murphington]

Both iconic. Let’s have a discussion.

Now me, I’ve seen Goodfellas before I saw Casino. I’ve seen Goodfellas no less than 10 times now and I’ve probably seen Casino like, 4 or 5 times or so. They’re both the kind of movies where once you put ‘em on, you don’t really stop watching until they’re over.

Which do you prefer?

[Brother Mouzone]

why-not-both-why-not.gif

[Willy Wanker]

Both great, but Goodfellas hands down.

[Vlad_]

Had to go with Goodfellas. But that's like comparing an amazing steak, to an amazing steak that just has that extra something...

[b Murphington]

why-not-both-why-not.gif

Because no!

[b Murphington]

Had to go with Goodfellas. But that's like comparing an amazing steak, to an amazing steak that just has that extra something...

Now what about The Irishman? Cuz when I first saw it, I thought it was too long winded, but upon my second viewing, it got better.

[Brother Mouzone]

Because no!

Casino IMHO it has better cinematography, Its splitting hairs though

[Brother Mouzone]

Now what about The Irishman? Cuz when I first saw it, I thought it was too long winded, but upon my second viewing, it got better.

RED : Not in the same league as Casino or Goodfellas , A Bronx Tale , Donnie Brasco, Gotti (HBO) one are in the same league though .The Godfather is in its own category as the GOAT

[The Big Dunn]

Goodfellas by the slimmest of margins.

[Vlad_]

Now what about The Irishman? Cuz when I first saw it, I thought it was too long winded, but upon my second viewing, it got better.

I liked it.