Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Super-six ATG version?

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
    #1

    Super-six ATG version?

    Hey guys, i saw Stallone60's thread with, the supersix of the 90s in great britain. and seeing that made me think of an idea. make a supersix in the original weightclasses with the ATG's.

    but, the problem is that i am kind of new to boxing, (3-4 years) so i dont have close to enough knowledge to do this. so i was hoping if anyone would find this interesting they could do it.

    look into his thread, my proposal is to do it as like him as possible. or do it your way [a multiple choice poll would be nice]

    i just thought it would be interesting compared to the same old Mayweather-Pac threads in NSB, so i posted it here hoping for some knowledge bombs

    thanks and good luck
    #2
    My ATG 168 Super six would include:

    1. Bob Fitzsimmons
    2. Harry Greb
    3. Billy Conn
    4. Joe Calzaghe
    5. Bernard Hopkins
    6. James Toney


    ^^^That would air on the Showtime Card while HBO will have Roy Jones who will fight the winner of the super six.

    I didnt include Ray Leonard because he deserves to be in a WW S6.
    Last edited by Joeyzagz; 06-08-2010, 03:28 PM.

    Comment

      #3
      Originally posted by JoeyZagz View Post
      My ATG 168 Super six would include:

      1. Bob Fitzsimmons
      2. Harry Greb
      3. Billy Conn
      4. Joe Calzaghe
      5. Bernard Hopkins
      6. James Toney


      ^^^That would air on the Showtime Card while HBO will have Roy Jones who will fight the winner of the super six.

      I didnt include Ray Leonard because he deserves to be in a WW S6.
      ah, good one
      who do you think would have won? and what about when the winner faced Jones? (all prime for prime of course)

      Comment

        #4
        Originally posted by RockyB View Post
        ah, good one
        who do you think would have won? and what about when the winner faced Jones? (all prime for prime of course)
        Think jones would have beat the winner of any of those at SMW.

        Comment

          #5
          HW Super Six
          1. Ali
          2. Foreman
          3. Lewis
          4. Marciano
          5. Holmes
          6. Tyson


          I think my list prime for prime would be a great super six, tyson were debateable where he lay's in ATG list, he has to be inclued as i am going prime for prime!

          Comment

            #6
            Originally posted by Undroppable View Post
            HW Super Six
            1. Ali
            2. Foreman
            3. Lewis
            4. Marciano
            5. Holmes
            6. Tyson


            I think my list prime for prime would be a great super six, tyson were debateable where he lay's in ATG list, he has to be inclued as i am going prime for prime!
            Replace Lewis for Bowe and Marciano for Johnson, I feel Liston needs to be there but I don't want to take anyone else out :S

            Comment

              #7
              Originally posted by Undroppable View Post
              HW Super Six
              1. Ali
              2. Foreman
              3. Lewis
              4. Marciano
              5. Holmes
              6. Tyson


              I think my list prime for prime would be a great super six, tyson were debateable where he lay's in ATG list, he has to be inclued as i am going prime for prime!
              spot on mate

              Comment

                #8
                Originally posted by NChristo View Post
                Replace Lewis for Bowe and Marciano for Johnson, I feel Liston needs to be there but I don't want to take anyone else out :S
                I was going to put liston in, but to me the others are better prime for prime. Lewis was better the bowe IMO, more constistant and would add something HW super six. Marciano has to be there, 49-0 as a HW is a once in a life time thing, along with a good resume has to be in.

                Comment

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Undroppable View Post
                  I was going to put liston in, but to me the others are better prime for prime. Lewis was better the bowe IMO, more constistant and would add something HW super six. Marciano has to be there, 49-0 as a HW is a once in a life time thing, along with a good resume has to be in.
                  kk then, think there's too many great HW for people to ever decide on 1 list, Louis needs to be on there as well, shame there can only be 6 :/

                  Prime for prime I'd pick Bowe over Lewis any day, much more skilled at his peak imo.
                  If you're going by achievements though then Lewis is greater.

                  Comment

                    #10
                    what about welterweight, middleweight and lightweight?

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X
                    TOP